We analysed 100,000+ drives from real data centers. Some brands are absolute tanks. Others? Not so much.
By The Storage Team
EasyDriveCompare.com
You've probably heard the stories: "WD Red is good for NAS," "Seagate BarraCuda is terrible," "Enterprise drives never fail."
Some of that's true. Most of it isn't. And if you're making a £5,000 (or $6,300) investment in storage without checking the actual data, you're rolling the dice.
So let's talk numbers. Real numbers. The Q3 2025 Drive Stats report tracked 100,000+ drives in actual data centers and hyperscale environments. No marketing nonsense—just failure rates and MTBF (Mean Time Between Failures) data.
The standout winners—and the red flags.
Annual failure rate: 0.34%. These things are built like tanks for 24/7 operation. Cost a bit more (£220–£450 / $280–$570), but they earn it.
Annual failure rate: 0.42%. Solid alternative. Slightly higher failure rate than WD Red, but many users swear by them. Price is comparable (£210–£430 / $270–$550).
Annual failure rate: 2.7%. That's 8x worse than IronWolf Pro. Consumer drives aren't designed for NAS, and the data proves it. Don't use these in always-on scenarios, no matter how cheap they are (£50–£130 / $65–$165).
Annual failure rate: 1.8%. Not terrible for a laptop drive, but nowhere near as reliable as the Red/IronWolf lines. Use for your PC, but don't bet your backup on one.
Here's what jumps out: there's a massive difference between a drive designed to run 8 hours a day and one designed to run 24/7.
A consumer BarraCuda in your gaming PC? Fine. A BarraCuda in a NAS that's spinning 24/7? That's not a price-saving move, that's a data-loss speedrun.
The failure rates tell the story. Enterprise and NAS-class drives have workload-rated components, better cooling, and firmware tuned for continuous operation. They last longer. Period.
Some manufacturers are sneaking Shingled Magnetic Recording (SMR) drives into product lines that traditionally used CMR (Conventional Magnetic Recording).
If your NAS is running RAID 5 or 6, an SMR drive can cause the whole array to degrade during recovery. We've seen people lose 16TB (£2,000+ / $2,500+) of data because they didn't check this.
Always buy CMR for NAS. Always. The price difference is small (usually £10–20 / $15–25 per drive), and it's the difference between sleeping soundly and losing everything.
The data is clear: you get what you pay for. NAS drives cost more for a reason. CMR matters. Reliability isn't a gamble if you know the numbers.
Compare Reliable Drives Now